Next time you take a long-haul flight, look out of the window at the engine. There is a good chance the name on it is Rolls-Royce. Yes, that Rolls-Royce.
The airline almost certainly does not pay for that engine the way you would expect. It pays Rolls-Royce for every hour the engine flies. If the engine has an issue, Rolls-Royce pays.
It was not always like this. Rolls-Royce used to sell the engine and leave others to keep it flying. Then it went straight to the airline and sold the flying.
Last week, Adobe did the same thing. For agencies, it is the second time this has happened.
In June, in The Free Half, I wrote: “Those in the deathly middle built their infrastructure and their margin around two activities: production and media buying.”
The platforms are going around agencies on the buying. With Google’s Performance Max and Meta’s Advantage+, a marketer hands over a budget, a goal and some assets, and the platform does the rest. Agencies still run many of those campaigns, and run them well. But the platform sets the terms.
Adobe is now going round agencies on the making. Two things stopped it before: its tools were hard to use, and it charged by the seat. It has now changed both.
When the engine maker went direct
For years Rolls-Royce sold engines. Keeping them flying was a separate business. Airlines’ own engineers and independent workshops earned their living from it.
Then Rolls-Royce started selling the flying hour, straight to the airline. TaaS. Thrust-as-a-Service. It could do that for two reasons. It read the data coming off its engines, so it knew when the work was needed. And it took the risk when an engine failed.
The effect was large. By 2019, on Rolls-Royce’s own count, about 90% of its big engines were on these contracts. One aviation consultancy counted no fully independent workshops left on those engines, against about thirty on the main rival engine.
To be clear, I am not comparing what agencies do with servicing an engine. Agencies create, and the best are worth every penny. I am comparing how the money is earned. For thirty years, agencies have earned part of their living by operating Adobe’s tools for clients.
Adobe is going direct
A year ago I wrote that Adobe was fighting from the middle out, trying to make both agencies and platforms a little less necessary. At its MAX conference last week it took the next step.
It (yes, like everyone) put AI agents inside Premiere, Illustrator, InDesign and After Effects. You say what you want, the agent shows you its plan, and then it does the work. It showed agents that keep working in the background, sorting assets and getting content ready for each channel. And for big companies, one tool now plans, makes and publishes a campaign from a single conversation, while another learns a brand’s rules and then resizes and rearranges designs for each format.
Put simply: Adobe used to sell the tools. Now it is selling the work.
The question for an agency is: selling it to whom?
Adobe does not publish how many of its customers are brands and how many are agencies, and six agency groups agreed in April to build on its platform. So nobody can tell you that clients have left their agencies for Adobe. I am not saying that.
I am saying Adobe is building the road, and inviting agencies to help build it. Fifteen months ago, in The Extinction Level Event, I wrote that Adobe’s way round agencies was probably the cleverest, “because it appears collaborative while systematically transferring strategic control.”
So judge Adobe by what it is building.
The wall that kept clients out
For thirty years, one thing kept clients from doing this work themselves. Adobe’s tools were hard. Photoshop and Premiere took years to learn, and agencies had the people who had learned them. Canva grew by serving everyone who had not.
Adobe is now taking that wall down itself.
Since last December, Photoshop, Express and Acrobat have worked inside ChatGPT, free. You describe the change you want in plain words.
Express has an AI assistant made for people who are not designers.
At MAX, Adobe added assistants to Illustrator and InDesign. It also showed a way for a designer to package a job as a simple app that anyone in the company can run.
It sells a product so that marketing teams can make their own ads and emails. Adobe’s product lead told The Drum: “It’s built for marketers to be able to self-serve.”
Adobe’s own customer stories say what this is for. Its story about Currys, the electricals retailer, lists cutting agency costs as a goal and claims a saving of 50% to 70% on one campaign.
Adobe’s accounts point the same way. It now reports its customers in two groups: creative and marketing professionals in one, business people and consumers in the other. The second group grew faster last quarter, 16% against 13%.
There is a twist here. That wall protected Adobe too, because people who have spent years learning a tool do not switch. Adobe is giving up its own protection to reach the marketer. A company only does that when it has decided who its next customer is.
Paid by the flying hour
Rolls-Royce explains how Adobe plans to be paid for this.
Adobe has sold seats for more than a decade: one person, one licence, one monthly fee. AI breaks that. One person now does the work of several, and an AI agent needs no seat at all.
So Adobe is moving to charging for use. The unit is the credit. A credit is a measure of computing power, and it costs about half a cent. A seat only earns when the customer has trained people. A credit earns from anyone who asks.
Adobe can charge this way because, like Rolls-Royce, it sees the whole machine. Its products already cover the brief, the making, the approval and the publishing. The one thing it did not supply was the labour. Now it does.
This matters most for big brands, where the files, the legal cover and the approvals all run through Adobe. And big brands are where agency production lives.
The squeeze agencies were already in
Most production scope on the agency side is now paid for by the output. The client pays a set price for each version or adaptation. By my estimate, the price of the same unit of production has been falling by between 10% and 20% a year.
Take the mid point. At 15%, an agency has to make 17.65% more adaptations every year just to earn what it earned the year before. Keep that up for six years and it is making more than two and a half times as many, for the same money.
So production has only kept its head above water by making far more assets. But a brand only has so many markets, formats and audiences. As I wrote in February, in Production Has Five Moats: “Volume has a law of large numbers limit. Costs don’t have a lower limit.”
Agencies are proud of having moved from charging for hours to charging for outputs. Adobe has just gone the other way. It charges for an input again. The input is compute.
That shows where the price of an adaptation is heading: towards the cost of the compute. When work is priced by compute, a hundred more versions add almost nothing to the bill.
For agencies, don’t just be an engine then.
Go back to the window seat.
That engine will carry you across an ocean. It will not suggest and inspire you where to go.
Rolls-Royce has never told an airline where to fly. It keeps the engines turning, and it is paid for every hour they turn. Adobe wants the same thing: to keep the making turning, and to be paid for every hour it does.
Nobody remembers a flight for its engine. They remember where it took them. And this is where agencies still have and can keep an upper hand: both being an engine AND inspiring clients where they can fly, with judgement and taste.
That is the simple truth about AI, in every kind of work. The more of the making the machines do, the more taste and judgement matter. The cheaper it gets to go anywhere, the more it is worth to know where to go.
In June I wrote: “The half they gave away is the half that survives.” Agencies sold the engine and gave away the destination.
Let Adobe have the engine. Charge for the destination.
If Adobe keeps the engine running, where will you tell your client to fly?
Brandflow is written by Justin Billingsley, who has spent his career on all three sides of the industry’s table: senior client, global agency leader, technology founder. If this was useful, subscribe here: Brandflow lands by email every Monday and Thursday.

